The 15 Best Mascaras of All Time Tested by Beauty Experts 2023

The 15 Best Mascaras of All Time Tested by Beauty Experts. Regardless of the makeup you choose for today, without mascara, the look will not look complete. This is the same beauty ingredient that is present in the cosmetic bag of both lovers of bright make-up and fans of nude images in the no makeup style. However, you yourself know that it can take years to find the perfect product.

best mascara for short lashes

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Mascaras

Let’s figure out together which mascaras is better to use in what situations:

  • The universal lengthening mascara suits short, long, and thin lashes and works mainly due to the thick applicator with short bristles (regular or silicone). She paints them well and separates them, regardless of whether she is a budget or premium segment. Special fibers are often added to the formula of lengthening mascaras: they attach to the tips of the cilia and add length to them.
  • Bulk mascara, according to makeup artists, is good for soft and sparse eyelashes. Its fluffy and thick brush picks up the product well in the right amount and evenly distributes it through the hairs. As for the formula, it often contains waxes, silicones, and various micro-beads to envelop each hair and increase its volume. During application, bulk mascara is more likely to show on the upper eyelid due to its large applicator, which picks up a lot of product if it is not waterproof. Prints can be easily removed with a cotton swab and micellar water – the effect of a wide-open look is worth it!
  • Curling mascara is a good option for owners of coarse and straight eyelashes, especially in a duet with a curler-curling iron. Recognizable by its concave or rounded brush and a special formula that softens the hairs and dries instantly to set the result. You can enhance the wow effect by painting over the cilia from the very roots with twisting movements.

Choosing a Mascara

Brush type

Now manufacturers offer a lot of different brushes of the most intricate shapes. You can choose any one that is more convenient for you.

It is worth paying attention to such nuances:

  • Rubber or silicone brushes are the best for creating a natural effect of fluffy and long eyelashes without too much drama. But they are not designed for straight hard hairs, because. can glue them.
  • For thick lashes, the best are long-haired applicators. They can well divide and paint over each hair without gluing.

There is a type of eyelash that turns into “spider legs” from any applicator and mascara, regardless of the quality of the product. In this case, before staining, they should be combed, for example, with a brush.

Top 15 Mascaras of 2023

Volumetric mascara is a real favorite of all tops. Probably because, like no other, it can give the look depth and mystery. Let’s start with it:

  • Dizzy volume – Mascara well separates the eyelashes, makes them fluffy, and gives expressiveness to the look. Thanks to a comfortable brush, it is evenly applied and distributed without forming lumps. With it, your make-up will be persistent, and the effect will last throughout the day.
  • Emotional expressiveness –  You will fall in love with this mascara as it creates incredibly voluminous lashes. A convenient brush easily twists and makes a perfect bend. In addition, it is stable, even without prior application of a primer. Perfect!
  • The Volume of a Million Eyelashes haute couture – a mini-revolution in the world of mascaras with the effect of false eyelashes. Its silicone brush with 408 extra-fine bristles, combined with a formula based on silk proteins, ideally separates and adds volume. A separate pleasure is a subtle floral scent that is noticeable upon application.
  • Stage volume -Its applicator covers every hair, even in “uncomfortable” places in the corners of the eyes. Separation, hold and volume are created by rice bran and wax.
  • Colossal volume – The iconic yellow mascara from Maybelline and the perfect addition to smoky makeup. Creates a matte jet-black finish & up to 9x fuller lashes!
  • Ultra volume – Its soft texture and natural waxes in the composition make the eyelashes amazingly voluminous until the evening. A comfortable brush with long bristles prevents them from sticking together, and gentle care is provided by natural acids, vitamin E, and panthenol.
  • Doll volume -New-generation ceramides have been added to this mascara. Thanks to them and the applicator with rigid bristles, the eyelashes get maximum volume and flawless staining. Does not cause allergies in those who wear lenses and Tested by Beauty Experts  owners of sensitive eyes.
  • Volume and curl -Her feature is a special curved brush, which in one movement gives the eyelashes a bend and a triple volume. Contains vegetable resins for durability and natural oils for gentle care.
  • Ultra color and ultra volume – Its peculiarity is in jet black, which gives depth and drama to the look. In addition, it is saturated with vitamin E, B5, and silk proteins, which effectively care for eyelashes and nourish and strengthen them. So caring care and lasting color are guaranteed.

Dizzy volume mascara

You can also get 7 Creative Ways to Hidden Staining Hair at Home

  • Volume from roots to tips – Do you want eyelashes like in a photo from a glossy magazine? This unique mascara creates just such volume! It perfectly covers every hair from root to tip and makes the look as open as possible. Life hack: a luxurious make-up with GlamBee Pop-Cool will be complemented by ultra-thin eyeliner and shadows with different effects.
  • Sensational length and volume -Her unusual fan brush has two types of villi. Short ones create Tested by Beauty Experts  a voluminous effect, and long ones separate and open up the look.
  • False eyelash effect – Max Factor False Lash Effect with a cone-shaped applicator. The bristles of different heights capture even short lashes. As a result, they look very thick, and the look is expressive.
  • Extreme lengthening – The secret of an expressive open look is in special pigments, the saturation of which is twice as intense as that of ordinary mascaras. The miniature flexible brush colors even the smallest hairs, compacting them and lengthening them by 60%.
  • Eyelashes in XXXL format – Creates dizzying volume & separates. Its feature is in a fluffy brush and a pleasant creamy texture.


How often should I replace my mascaras?

It is recommended to replace your mascara every three to four months. Mascara has a relatively short shelf life due to its liquid formula, which can become a breeding ground for bacteria over time. Regularly replacing your mascara ensures optimal performance and helps prevent eye infections.

Can I mix different mascaras for better results?

Yes, you can experiment with mixing different mascaras to achieve your desired results. Combining a Tested by Beauty Experts lengthening mascara with a volumizing mascara, for example, can give you the best of both worlds—long and full lashes. Just make sure to apply each mascara in thin layers to avoid clumping.

What should I do if my mascaras dry out?

If your mascara starts to dry out and becomes difficult to apply, there are a few tricks you can try. Firstly, avoid pumping the mascara wand in and out of the tube, as this introduces air and dries out the product faster. Instead, swirl the wand inside the tube to pick up the product. If your mascara is still too dry, you can add a few drops of sterile saline solution or eye drops to revive its consistency.

Is it safe to wear mascaras every day?

Yes, it is generally safe to wear mascara daily, as long as you follow proper hygiene practices and choose high-quality products. However, if you experience any irritation, redness, or discomfort, it’s advisable to discontinue use and Tested by Beauty Experts  consult a dermatologist or ophthalmologist. Additionally, remember to remove your mascara thoroughly before going to bed to avoid potential eye infections.

Can mascaras cause eyelash damage?

When used correctly and with care, mascara should not cause significant damage to your eyelashes. However, rough removal techniques, excessive rubbing, or using expired mascaras can lead to lash breakage. To maintain Tested by Beauty Experts healthy lashes, be gentle when removing your mascara, use a makeup remover specifically designed for the eyes, and avoid sharing mascaras to reduce the risk of contamination.